Caribbean & Mexico

“Surviving” Peter Island Resort, BVI

By Jon Whittle

Updated: January 28, 2014

A doughy photographer endures gourmet torture, sunburns, triathlons and torrid tubs at the BVI’s biggest private island resort. — Jon Whittle

BVI Travel Guide | Where to Stay in the USVI | Best of the Caribbean

Peter Island | Island Destinations | British Virgin Islands | Island Beaches

It Started Well …

I didn’t need a banner to greet me upon arriving at Peter Island Resort & Spa. This view over Deadman’s Bay was enough welcome. With 32 ocean-view rooms, 20 suites, three villas and private beaches in all directions, what could go wrong? Jon Whittle

Arrival Miscue

I was brought over on the private resort ferry available to all guests. Pictured is the resort’s helipad for VIPs. Obviously, somebody forgot to include me on that list. To make myself feel more important, I landed my remote-control quadcopter right in the center of the giant “H.” Nobody was around to see how awesome I looked. Jon Whittle

Peter Island | Island Destinations | British Virgin Islands | Island Dining

Don’t Let the Smile Fool You

Executive chef Lisa Sellers is trying to kill me. Although she has a collection of knives to do the trick, she has instead taken the more insidious path of cooking Caribbean prawn cakes, followed by grilled jerk baby-lamb chops with a pulled-pork barbecue pizza on the side. No, she didn’t force-feed me, but each meal was gourmet torture. Jon Whittle

Peter Island | Island Destinations | British Virgin Islands | Island Gourmet Food

Seduced by Snapper

Here’s an example of what I was forced to eat: locally caught, whole-roasted snapper with vegetables grown from the resort’s garden. Was it delicious? Yes. Horribly, torturously delicious. And this was just lunch. Jon Whittle

Peter Island | Island Destinations | British Virgin Islands | Island Beach Front Villas

Room Snags

My room sat on the far end of Deadman’s Bay. The white dot on the hill is the Crow’s Nest Villa, with the best views in the BVI. For some reason, I was not booked into that heavenly space, though I believe I could’ve made great use of its 6,500 square feet, despite being alone. Hey, don’t crush my dreams. Jon Whittle

Peter Island | Island Destinations | British Virgin Islands | Island Beaches | Private Beaches

Sand Everywhere

Choosing beaches is tough for Islands photographers. But here I had virtually all of Peter Island’s eight beaches to myself. So I tapped my inner millionaire, and dramatically agonized over where I should sunburn my body. Pictured: Big Reef Bay. Jon Whittle

Stubborn Management

White Bay Beach was named for the color of my back before I spent the morning photographing it without sunscreen. I later asked management to change its name to Blister Beach, but they wouldn’t budge. Despite my sunburn, it’s hard to despise a view like this. And yes, another beach all to myself. Jon Whittle

Peter Island | Island Destinations | British Virgin Islands | Island Activities | Outdoor Activites

I’ll Catch Up Later

The good folks at Peter Island were the fittest people I’ve ever had the pleasure of acting fit around. Here, trainer Chris Ghiorse and GM Wilbert Mason show off what the human physique should look like. Sadly, my doughy shape can no longer be attributed to baby fat. Jon Whittle

Peter Island | Island Destinations | British Virgin Islands | Island Activities | Biking

But I’m on Vacation

Doughy shape be damned, the Peter Island crew roped me into their triathlon, an on-demand offering for those visitors who feel sitting by the pool having a drink is just too relaxing. Fortunately, Chris convinced me to give it a go with no mention of how he lost a coin toss to be my triathlon partner. Jon Whittle

Peter Island | Island Destinations | British Virgin Islands | Island Activities | Outdoor Activities | Running

It Sure Looks Inviting …

Everyone knows that running was a sport created by Satan. When Chris left me to help others, a beautiful Asian woman lapped me so many times she eventually brought water to rouse me awake from a bed of cacti overlooking Deadman’s Bay. Pain never looked so pretty. Jon Whittle

Peter Island | Island Destinations | British Virgin Islands | Island Activities | Outdoor Activities | Swimming

My Kind of Racing

Thankfully, the triathlon had us kayak instead of swim. I didn’t mind finishing this last leg virtually alone in the waters off Peter Island. What race? Jon Whittle

Peter Island | Island Destinations | British Virgin Islands | Island Sunsets

A Perfectly Horrible Sunset

The beauty of this BVI sunset coaxed me from icing my legs into an upright position just long enough to snap this shot. A perfect end to a horrendously rewarding day. But wait, wasn’t there talk of a spa? Jon Whittle

Peter Island | Island Destinations | British Virgin Islands | Island Spas

Now You Show Me the Hot Tub

Peter Island’s spa is 10,000 square feet of relaxation and primping. Without a doubt, the spa was my favorite part of the trip —especially this hot tub. Jon Whittle

Peter Island | Island Destinations | British Virgin Islands | Island Boardwalks

A Final Request (or Two)

Here’s the view from my villa on the beach, along with a not-so-subtle hint: There are a lot of choices for Caribbean getaways, and Peter Island is one I’d recommend wholeheartedly. One request: Take me with you. Actually, two requests: No more running, please. Jon Whittle

More: Beaches, British Virgin Islands, Caribbean & Mexico, resorts, Travel Guides

Email Newsletters and Special Offers

Sign up for Islands emails to receive features on travel destinations, event listings and product reviews as well as special offers on behalf of Islands’ partners.

By signing up you agree to receive communications from Islands and select partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy. You may opt out of email messages/withdraw consent at any time.

“Surviving” Peter Island Resort, BVI

It Started Well …

Arrival Miscue

Don’t Let the Smile Fool You

Seduced by Snapper

Room Snags

Sand Everywhere

Stubborn Management

I’ll Catch Up Later

But I’m on Vacation

It Sure Looks Inviting …

My Kind of Racing

A Perfectly Horrible Sunset

Now You Show Me the Hot Tub

A Final Request (or Two)

Email Newsletters and Special Offers

More Caribbean & Mexico

Inside the Last Available Luxury Penthouse at Fairmont Residences Mayakoba

A Visit to Mazatlán Offers the Perfect Combination of Mexico’s Past, Present, and Future

You Can Rent the Most Private Island in the World

Nonstop Flights from Minneapolis

Read More

How to Make the Most of Your Newport and Narragansett Getaway

Everything You Need to Know about Cruising on the Riverside Mozart

Let the Experts Plan Your First Epic Adventure to the Galapagos Islands

Two Great Ways to Save Big on a Stay at Hilton Hawaiian Village Waikiki Beach Resort